Pie Insurance

Pie Insurance sells business insurance in Florida.

In Florida since 1915.

Taking new business policies

Florida company code 01100, NAIC 21857.

Get a quote from an independent agent

Checked by

Did your Pie Insurance renewal go up?

A licensed Florida agent shops other companies for you. It is free and takes about 5 minutes.

or call (727) 997-5999

Chat

Free. No junk mail. No spam calls.

Policies in force

Not available

No count on file

Latest rate change

Not available

No rate change on file

Financial strength

Not available

No rating on file

Complaints

Not available

NAIC

Can I get a policy?

We're still gathering this company's rules. Call and we'll check for you.

Talk to a licensed agent (727) 997-5999

Two choices when your Pie Insurance rate goes up

You have two choices. One 5 minute call covers both.

  • Keep Pie Insurance, switch your agent. You sign one form. Same company, same coverage, same price. Only your agent changes, to one who answers the phone.
  • Shop it. Your new agent checks 80+ companies at every renewal.
Talk to a licensed agent (727) 997-5999

Or send a message

Before you call, see the Florida home insurance renewal checklist.

Shop your renewal in one call

One call. A licensed agent shops other companies for you, free.

(727) 997-5999 Shop my renewal Chat

What's changed recently

Is Pie Insurance leaving Florida? No sign of it. On Oct 21, 2026 their site listed Florida for workers' comp, and OIR showed both of their insurers as active. As of Nov 2, 2026. Source: pieinsurance.com.

  1. A second Pie company gets their license

    OIR says Pie Casualty got their Florida license on Oct 18, 2023.

  2. The main Pie company gets their license

    OIR says the company now named The Pie Insurance Company first got their Florida license on September 1, 1915. Pie itself was founded in 2017.

See every Pie Insurance update

Rate history

No rate filings tracked yet.

Want your Pie Insurance renewal shopped?

A licensed Florida agent shops other companies for you. It is free and takes about 5 minutes.

or call (727) 997-5999

Chat

Free. No junk mail. No spam calls.

111 years in Florida

In Florida since 1915. Has paid claims through 28 hurricanes.

19201930194019501960197019801990200020102020Agnes (1972, Category 1 at Florida landfall)Agnes Cat 1Eloise (1975, Category 3 at Florida landfall)Eloise Cat 3David (1979, Category 2 at Florida landfall)David Cat 2Elena (1985, Category 3 at Florida landfall)Elena Cat 3Kate (1985, Category 2 at Florida landfall)Kate Cat 2Floyd (1987, Category 1 at Florida landfall)Floyd Cat 1Andrew (1992, Category 5 at Florida landfall)Andrew Cat 5Erin (1995, Category 2 at Florida landfall)Erin Cat 2Opal (1995, Category 3 at Florida landfall)Opal Cat 3Earl (1998, Category 1 at Florida landfall)Earl Cat 1Georges (1998, Category 2 at Florida landfall)Georges Cat 2Irene (1999, Category 1 at Florida landfall)Irene Cat 1Charley (2004, Category 4 at Florida landfall)Charley Cat 4Frances (2004, Category 2 at Florida landfall)Frances Cat 2Ivan (2004)IvanJeanne (2004, Category 3 at Florida landfall)Jeanne Cat 3Dennis (2005, Category 3 at Florida landfall)Dennis Cat 3Wilma (2005, Category 3 at Florida landfall)Wilma Cat 3Matthew (2016)MatthewIrma (2017, Category 4 at Florida landfall)Irma Cat 4Michael (2018, Category 5 at Florida landfall)Michael Cat 5Ian (2022, Category 4 at Florida landfall)Ian Cat 4Nicole (2022, Category 1 at Florida landfall)Nicole Cat 1Idalia (2023, Category 3 at Florida landfall)Idalia Cat 3Debby (2024, Category 1 at Florida landfall)Debby Cat 1Helene (2024, Category 4 at Florida landfall)Helene Cat 4Milton (2024, Category 3 at Florida landfall)Milton Cat 3Isaías (2026, Category 2 at Florida landfall)Isaías Cat 2

Compare Pie Insurance side by side

Pie Insurance side by side with State Farm and Slide
Pie Insurance State Farm Slide
New policies Taking new policies Checked Nov 2, 2026 Taking new policies Checked Nov 2, 2026 Taking new policies Checked Nov 2, 2026
Florida policies Not available 654,641 Florida OIR, Jul 31, 2026 475,227 Florida OIR, Jul 31, 2026
Latest rate change Not available +0.8% Home, from Jan 15, 2026 Not available
Complaint index Not available 0.63 NAIC, 2025, nationwide, homeowners. 1.00 is average. 0.88 NAIC, 2025, nationwide, homeowners. 1.00 is average.
Financial rating Not available A- (Excellent) AM Best A (Exceptional) Demotech, Oct 7, 2026
In Florida since 1915 1934 2022

Pick other companies to compare

People also compare with

  • State Farm Taking new policies

    State Farm sells home, condo, renters and auto policies in Florida. They use their own agents. Home policies come from State Farm Florida, a Florida only firm.

  • Slide Taking new policies

    Slide is a Tampa home insurer founded in 2021. They grew fast by taking on policies from Citizens, UPC, St. Johns and Farmers customers in Florida.

  • Tower Hill Taking new policies

    Tower Hill is a Gainesville insurer. They have covered Florida homes since 1972. New policies come from the member owned Tower Hill Insurance Exchange.

  • Frontline Taking new policies

    Frontline is the Lake Mary brand behind First Protective. New Florida home policies now come from their FIRE exchange, open statewide.

  • Citizens Taking new policies

    Citizens is run by the state and covers Florida homes when no private company will. They sell home, condo, renters and wind only plans.

More on our list of Florida commercial insurance companies.

Questions people ask about Pie Insurance

What is the Pie Insurance claims phone number?Call 844-581-0828.

Pie's claims page calls it a 24/7 claim line. Report a work injury within 24 hours if you can. You can also report it online or by email.

Source: Pie Insurance workers' comp claims page, read Oct 21, 2026

What is the Pie Insurance customer service number?For workers' comp, call 855-705-2716.

The line is open 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. Eastern, Monday to Friday.

Source: Pie Insurance contact page, read Oct 21, 2026

Does Pie Insurance sell workers' comp in Florida?Yes.

Pie's list of states for workers' comp includes Florida. They sell in 40 states and Washington, D.C. You can get a quote on their site or through an agent.

Source: Pie Insurance States We Serve and home pages, read Oct 21, 2026

Is Pie Insurance licensed in Florida?Yes.

OIR lists two Pie firms as active in Florida. Pie Casualty Insurance Company got their Florida license in 2023.

Source: Florida OIR company search, read Oct 20, 2026

Who pays my workers' comp claim if Pie Insurance fails?A state fund pays.

Florida law says each workers' comp insurer must join it. If a court closes an insurer that cannot pay their debts, the fund pays covered claims, within limits. Its name is the Florida Workers' Compensation Insurance Guaranty Association.

Source: Sections 631.904 and 631.911, Florida Statutes, read Oct 20, 2026

How do I change how I pay Pie Insurance?Sign in to your Pie online account.

There you can add a bank account or a credit or debit card for your regular payments. If you pay through your payroll company, ask them to change it instead.

Source: Pie Insurance, Online Account Tutorial, read Oct 25, 2026

Still deciding? Let us shop your Pie Insurance renewal.

A licensed Florida agent shops other companies for you. It is free and takes about 5 minutes.

or call (727) 997-5999

Chat

Free. No junk mail. No spam calls.

Pie Insurance reviews and complaints: what the public data shows

Pie Insurance rating

We have no financial strength rating for Pie Insurance.

Florida does not publish complaint or rating data for Pie Insurance. What we do have: Pie Insurance has been in Florida since 1915.

No star ratings and no user reviews, only public data.